(CNN)Imagine if one day Jennifer Lawrence was walking the red carpet in Los Angeles and the next she vanished completely with no word about where she was.
Fan Bingbing, one of China’s highest-paid and most bankable stars, has appeared in both Chinese and Western films, including the multimillion-dollar X-Men franchise.
Across the country, her face once adorned thousands of advertisements, her star power used to sell a galaxy of luxury brands, from Cartier to Louis Vuitton. She was a regular sight at major award shows and fashion ceremonies. In 2015, Time Magazine named her China’s “most famous actress.”
In an article by state media Securities Daily on September 6, which was later deleted, the publication said Fan had been brought “under control and about to receive legal judgment.”
No official statement has been made as to Fan’s whereabouts, or any potential criminal charges against the actress.
However, in a country where top celebrities are forced to keep an inoffensive public profile to stay in the Chinese government’s good graces, people have drawn their own conclusions about the actress’ location.
“If you are a billionaire, then that is something that obviously you can enjoy to a certain extent, but you’ve got to be very, very wary that you don’t at any stage cross a red line of some sort and fall afoul of the Chinese Communist Party,” Fergus Ryan, a cyber analyst with the Australian Strategic Policy Institute, told CNN.
In 2011, the country’s best-known artist, Ai Weiwei, was detained for almost three months during which time his whereabouts were unclear. He was later released after he signed a confession authorities described as being related to tax evasion.
Yin yang contracts
Fan’s purported problems began when alleged copies of a film contract she had signed were leaked onto China’s social media in late May.
According to state tabloid Global Times, she had two different contracts, one for tax purposes saying she was paid $1.5 million (10 million yuan) and a separate, private contract for $7.5 million (50 million yuan).
It’s a practice known in China as “yin-yang contracts,” a form of tax evasion where the first, smaller contract is reported to authorities while the second, larger one is treated as tax-free income.
Fan’s team issued a furious denial at the time but the actress hasn’t been seen in public since the dispute.
In September, China’s Beijing Normal University released a report, lauded as the first “in the world” and heavily promoted in Chinese state media, which ranked the country’s stars by their level of “social responsibility.” Fan was ranked last, with a score of 0 out of 100.
A producer with a major Chinese studio told CNN the practice of having two contracts, one of them smaller to avoid paying too much tax, was “universal” in the film industry.
He said everyone was worried following Fan’s disappearance, especially because “almost every contract has some irregularities” and won’t stand up to a serious audit.
Like other industry insiders CNN spoke to, he declined to be named due to the political sensitivity of the topic.
Scaring celebrities into line
Jonathan Landreth, former Beijing-based Asia editor for the Hollywood Reporter and longtime observer of China’s entertainment industry, told CNN the Chinese Communist Party was treading a tricky line, keen to use high-profile celebrities to sell the “Chinese Dream,” but not wanting to promote the stark income divide.
“Maybe this is just scaring folk to … start paying taxes. If someone were to get busted, then I think it would send a ripple effect to how film production goes forward in the coming years,” Landreth said.
China steps up censorship on the Internet
An executive in a foreign film studio’s China office told CNN the lack of A-list celebrities in China increased the bargaining power and earnings of a lucky few — high-profile performers like Fan.
But while cracking down on them might solve other problems, she said it wouldn’t help address the fundamental lack of talent across the Chinese film and television industries.
Combined with strict ideological control, such measures act only to create a “sad situation” in China’s creative industry, she said.
The controls, though, can only go so far. The Chinese government needs the high-profile celebrities to help drive commerce, both domestically and internationally, to promote China, said Landreth.
The crackdown may in fact be intended to solve a different problem facing authorities. “It has long been an open secret that a movie budget is a great place to hide money,” said Landreth.
The Communist Party’s leadership may hope that by shining a light on celebrity tax avoidance, it could deflect attention and avoid closer public scrutiny of the rumored corruption among top government officials and their families, Landreth told CNN.
Spreading ‘positive energy’
The Chinese Communist Party has long had an uncomfortable relationship with celebrities.
In recent years, state media has called on celebrities to spread “positive energy” on the internet. The threat of career-ending trouble with authorities has led the country’s stars to pay attention to the party’s wishes.
The result is a celebrity culture that has less in common with the salacious and controversial Hollywood familiar to the Western world. In China, celebrities often try to keep their reputations’ positive and inoffensive.
Australian analyst Ryan said when he lived in China, he worked with the publicity team for Chinese actress and singer Li Bingbing.
He encouraged Li to become more involved with environmental causes, including the United Nations Environment Program.
But Ryan said the team would never choose a cause, or take up a fight that was ahead of what the Communist Party was comfortable with, especially if it opposed current government policy.
“You would be foolish to go out ahead of the Chinese Communist Party and the Chinese authorities on issues and lead the way,” he said.
Despite the speculation and the concern, Ryan said it was possible the explanation for Fan’s disappearance was actually very simple.
“She possibly did something wrong … the evidence was put out there for all to see, I guess, in a way that put the authorities in a position where they had to come down hard on her,” he said.
Easily tap into the massive WP plugin market with WP Master Developer plugin creator for WordPress. 7 new built-in tools for rapid WP development: templates, Intellisense, auto-complete, 2500+ autopop WP functions, and instant help.
PushLotusSend 'push notifications' to your website visitors. Just copy/paste a piece of code on to your site to start building your list. The Standard version ($67) works in Chrome, Mozilla and Safari. No software installation necessary. The Pro version ($97) work
LaunchShark Volume 1 Second ChanceBuild 6 Figure Sales Funnels... Even If Optimizepress Makes You Curse Out Loud...
I design for 6 figure product launchers... now I want to give YOU the same pages I built for them!
Snapify OTO-1 PremiumUsing Snapify you can turn your Social Network content and #UGC into shoppable galleries for your online store, emails, blog and ad campaigns plus manage and secure the rights to digital content.
Snapify is built from the ground up to be a simpler yet smart
Passion Blog ProOver 8 Hours of Over the shoulders, behind the scenes look at how a Real Entrepreneur Shows Everything About Affiliate Marketing and Blog Building Strategies To Generate A Recurring Income Online. Demetris Shares his exact blueprint and methods using min
AdExpress LiteADEXPRESS Let’s Your Customers Design The Perfect Ads Graphics For their PPC Campaigns
on Facebook and Many Other Platforms Without Having To Worry About Photoshop, Design Skills, Getting the Right Dimensions or Hiring Designers To Do It For Them!
Shot Messenger FE [Agency]Use FB messenger as FREE Auto Responder with 100% Open Rate Guaranteed
In World's 1st Fb Messenger Marketing SuiteBuild Unlimited List, Broadcast Unlimited Messages To Unlimited Subscribers On Facebook
and Connect With Them Right Inside Their Fb Messenger
Instamate Premium YearlyInstamate is the worlds first all in 1 web based Instagram tool that finds the most viral content on FB, Instagram and Pinterest then allowing you to post and Schedule directed from the computer.
TrafficZion ProTrafficZion is a simple-to-setup software that virtually ANYONE can use to start getting consistent FREE traffic on complete autopilot from a reputable free platform for any niche possible.The traffic comes from a legit and overlooked traffic source.
Pixelmodo - BasicPixelModo is a cloud-based tool that lets you create Stunning Graphics, banners, ads, social media covers, capture and load any image or text from webpages directly into the editor, create Print on Demand Tshirt Graphics, access 2.5 million high quality i
Profit Lead Funnels Pro PackageAn upgrade for the Profit Lead Funnels. In the Pro Package you get 21 video bridge pages, 7 presell videos, 7 download pages, 35 banner graphics, DFY legal pages, and editable graphic suite!
IPL Elite - PRO DSInstant Product Lab - The Newbie-Friendly, Cloud Based Software That Creates High-Quality Info Products You Can Sell In Just 60 Seconds
Viddictive Templates ClubViddictive Template Club instantly adds 50+ templates to your account, in addition to 20 exclusive templates every month!
Viking MPLR Monthly 2017Viking PLR is an awesome collection of internet marketing related PLR packages each including a free report, an ebook, and a video course. These packages come with full private label rights and can be rebranded if you so choose. :)
DFY Niche Prophecies100% done-for-you service where we identify profitable future niches, and deliver one of them to you each month, so that you don’t need to do any “scouting” if you can’t or don’t want to.
Vizully PLATINUM ProVizully PLATINUM Edition Gets You BUYERS Hands-FREE With Your Unique Mini-Video Gifs and Moving Images On Social Networks For More Profits On Autopilot.
Pixel Studio FX 2018Drag and Drop Web Based Software - Instantly create e-book, kindle, cd, or software covers in minutes. Includes 250 done for you e-covers, 3,000 Unique Combinations in total! *LAUNCH SPECIAL* Includes Commercial/Enterprise License!
Long Tail Pro Rank Tracker Silver Annual PlanMeasure your success and keep tabs on how you're doing with the Rank Tracker feature in Long Tail Pro. The Silver Annual Plan includes 300 tracked keywords with weekly rank updates, 1 year access, Ranking History, and graph export feature!
The Cash Hive Membership - Director Level MonthlyJon Bowtell created The Cash Hive membership site to provide a deep level of training of his 7 Steps to Internet Success. With over 15 years of on-line sales experience and building several 6, 7 and 8 figure online business. A membership to The Cash Hiv
QuickAffiliatePro EnterpriseGet this Brand New Software That INSTANTLY Creates 1-Click SEO-Optimized and Traffic Pulling Affiliate Sites Stacked With Fresh, Unique Content and HOT Videos To Boost Sales and Affiliate Commissions 24*7 on Complete Autopilot.
My Product Store Smart AdsSmart ads allows you to add relevant affiliate offers to My Product Store and will automatically display the best performing offers high and more frequently to automatically maximize your income. A no brainer for any My Product Store Owner.